Crash Victim Recovers Full $115,000 Verdict After Missouri Appeal Rejects Comparative Fault Instruction

The Missouri Court of Appeals held a St. Louis County jury should never have been asked whether a driver hit by a car cutting across three lanes failed to keep a careful lookout, erased the 33 percent fault finding, and restored her full verdict without a new trial.

A jury can award an injured driver every dollar she asks for and still send her home with a third less, if the defense persuades the court to let the jury assign her a share of the blame. In Long v. Saltzman, No. ED114254 (Mo. Ct. App. E.D. Oct. 27, 2026), the Missouri Court of Appeals held that a St. Louis County jury should never have been asked whether the plaintiff failed to keep a careful lookout, because nothing in the record showed she could have seen the danger in time to do anything about it. The court struck the 33 percent fault assessed against her and entered judgment for the full $115,000.00 the jury found.

For injured drivers, the decision is a useful reminder that a comparative fault instruction is not something the defense gets just by asking. It has to be earned with evidence, and when it is not, the appellate court can fix the judgment without sending the case back for a second trial.

What Happened on Manchester Road

According to the opinion, Angie Long was driving east on Manchester Road in August 2017, at the speed limit, in the far right lane. Louise Saltzman was stopped in the U-turn lane on the far left. Saltzman accelerated to 30 to 35 miles per hour and cut across a solid white line and three lanes of traffic to reach a parking lot. She did not see Long. Long testified she could see a fairly long way down Manchester and did not see Saltzman’s car until it was already in her lane. She braked and swerved right. It was not enough.

Long sued in St. Louis County, and the case was tried to a jury in 2025. The jury found her total damages to be $115,000.00, then assessed 67 percent of the fault to Saltzman and 33 percent to Long. The trial court reduced the award accordingly and entered judgment for $77,050.00. Long’s motion for new trial was denied, and she appealed.

The Instruction the Defense Asked For

Saltzman first proposed a comparative fault instruction accusing Long of two things, excessive speed and failure to keep a careful lookout. The trial court rejected the speed theory, since Long was driving the limit, but allowed a revised instruction on lookout alone. That instruction is what let the jury assign Long a percentage of fault.

Missouri drivers have a duty to keep a careful lookout, and the duty is to see and to act. The Court of Appeals explained that a lookout instruction is proper only when there is substantial evidence that the driver, had she been paying attention, could have seen the other vehicle in time to take effective precautionary action. The question has two parts. Could the driver have seen the danger? And if so, could she have done something to avoid it?

Why the Court of Appeals Reversed

The court leaned on the Missouri Supreme Court’s decision in Hayes v. Price, 313 S.W.3d 645 (Mo. banc 2010). In Hayes, a motorcyclist with the right of way was hit by a driver turning left in front of him. The Supreme Court held that a driver with the right of way is entitled to assume others will yield until he has reason to know they will not, and he is not required to take evasive action before that point. Because there was no evidence the motorcyclist had any warning, the lookout instruction should not have been given.

The Eastern District found Long’s case materially the same. She was going straight, at the speed limit, in her own lane. Saltzman, in the court’s words, “gunshotted” across three lanes directly into Long’s path. Long had no reason to expect that, and there was no evidence she could or should have seen any sign of danger in time to avoid it. The record showed the opposite: the moment she saw Saltzman’s car, she braked and swerved. The instruction was unsupported, and because the jury used it to cut her recovery by a third, the error was prejudicial.

Why the Court Fixed the Judgment Instead of Ordering a New Trial

Long asked for a new trial, arguing that fault and damages were too intertwined to separate. The court disagreed, and its reasoning is the practical heart of the opinion. The damages instruction given to the jury, Instruction No. 10, told the jurors to determine Long’s total damages while disregarding any fault on her part, and expressly told them the judge would do the reduction. Juries are presumed to follow their instructions. So the $115,000.00 figure already represented the jury’s view of her full damages, untouched by the fault finding. Under Missouri Supreme Court Rule 84.14, the appellate court modified the judgment itself: 100 percent fault to Saltzman and a $115,000.00 award to Long. The judgment was affirmed in all other respects.

Why This Matters for Injured Drivers

Comparative fault is the most common way a defendant in a Missouri car crash case reduces what it owes. The argument is cheap to make and, once it reaches the jury, hard to undo. Jurors who hear “failure to keep a careful lookout” often split the difference even when the plaintiff did nothing wrong. This case is a reminder that the instruction requires actual evidence that the plaintiff could have seen the hazard and had time and room to react. A driver proceeding lawfully in her own lane is not required to anticipate that someone will bolt across three lanes of traffic in front of her.

The decision also shows why the wording of the damages instruction matters. Because the jury was told to find total damages without regard to fault, the appellate court could restore the full verdict without a retrial, saving the plaintiff another year and another trial. Henderson Law Firm’s personal injury practice handles St. Louis car crash cases from the first demand through trial and appeal, including the fight over whether a comparative fault instruction belongs in the case at all.

Takeaway

Long v. Saltzman holds that a comparative fault instruction for failure to keep a careful lookout cannot go to the jury without substantial evidence that the plaintiff could have seen the danger and avoided it. When a defendant cuts across traffic into the plaintiff’s lane, and the plaintiff reacts the instant the danger appears, that evidence is missing. The Eastern District erased the 33 percent fault finding and gave Long the full $115,000.00 the jury found, a difference of $37,950.00, without a second trial.

Tom Henderson
Tom Henderson
Articles: 22